PRODUCT-REVIEW-CREW

Best Lip Balms 2025 - Top 5 Compared

This comparison reviews five top-performing lip balms for 2025, each excelling in different categories. The Laneige Lip Glowy Balm stands out as the best overall for hydration with a glossy finish, while Aquaphor Healing Ointment offers the most budget-friendly healing formula. Rhode Peptide Lip Treatment combines hydration with peptide technology, Dr. Dan's Cortibalm provides medicated relief for severely chapped lips, and Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm delivers luxury scents with buildable color.

1Best Overall Hydration with Glossy Finish
Laneige Lip Glowy Balm - Best Overall Hydration with Glossy Finish Beauty and Personal Care
$19 - $22
The Laneige Lip Glowy Balm delivers exceptional hydration with a luxurious glossy finish, combining skincare benefits with cosmetic appeal in a portable tube.
BUY NOWTrusted site: Amazon.com
2Best Budget-Friendly Healing Formula
Aquaphor Healing Ointment - Best Budget-Friendly Healing Formula Beauty and Personal Care
$12 - $15
Aquaphor Healing Ointment provides exceptional healing for severely chapped lips at an affordable price, with dermatologist-recommended ingredients that repair and protect.
BUY NOWTrusted site: Amazon.com
3Best Glossy Hydration with Peptide Technology
Rhode Peptide Lip Treatment - Best Glossy Hydration with Peptide Technology Beauty and Personal Care
$22 - $24
Rhode Peptide Lip Treatment combines skincare benefits with a luxurious glossy finish, delivering hydration and subtle plumping effects through its peptide-infused formula.
BUY NOWTrusted site: Amazon.com

Product-Review-Crew's Comparison

Product-Review-Crew analyzed multiple data points to compare the top lip balms for 2025. The Laneige Lip Glowy Balm earns the top spot for its superior hydration, combining shea butter and murumuru butter in a non-sticky formula with a glossy finish. Its tinted shades make it ideal for those seeking both care and subtle color. However, its higher price and limited availability may deter some users. Aquaphor Healing Ointment ranks second as the most budget-friendly option, with its 41% petrolatum formula providing exceptional moisture retention. Its fragrance-free, multipurpose design suits sensitive skin, though the thick texture and tub packaging may not appeal to everyone. Rhode Peptide Lip Treatment takes third place with its innovative peptide technology, offering plumping benefits alongside high-shine hydration. The subtle sweet taste and non-sticky finish are positives, but the glossy formula may transfer more than matte options, and the applicator tip can accumulate product buildup.

Dr. Dan's Cortibalm ranks fourth as the best medicated option, featuring 1% hydrocortisone for severe chapping relief. Its hypoallergenic formula avoids common irritants, making it ideal for those with extreme dryness from medications or weather. However, it's not suitable for everyday preventive use and has limited retail availability. Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm rounds out the list as the best scented luxury option, with murumuru and shea butters for hydration and buildable color in appealing shades. While the delicious scents and texture are highlights, the high price point and strong fragrances may not suit all users. Each product serves distinct needs, from everyday hydration to medical relief, with variations in texture, finish, and price catering to different preferences.

1Laneige Lip Glowy Balm - Best Overall Hydration with Glossy Finish

Laneige Lip Glowy Balm
$19 - $22
BUY NOWTrusted site: Amazon.com
The Laneige Lip Glowy Balm delivers exceptional hydration with a luxurious glossy finish, combining skincare benefits with cosmetic appeal in a portable tube.
  • +Contains nourishing shea butter and murumuru butter
  • +Provides long-lasting hydration without stickiness
  • +Comes in multiple flattering tinted shades
  • -Higher price point than drugstore options
  • -Glossy finish may not appeal to those preferring matte
  • -Limited availability in some regions

The Laneige Lip Glowy Balm stands out as a top-tier lip treatment that bridges the gap between skincare and cosmetics. Its formula, enriched with shea butter and murumuru butter, provides deep hydration that lasts for hours, making it particularly effective for dry or chapped lips. The balm glides on smoothly with a cushiony texture that fills in fine lines while delivering a high-shine finish comparable to premium lip glosses. Unlike many glossy formulas, this product doesn't feel sticky or heavy on the lips. Available in several sheer tinted shades, each variation offers subtle color payoff that enhances natural lip tone without overpowering.

The slanted applicator allows for precise application and controlled product distribution. While the price point is higher than basic drugstore balms, the performance justifies the cost for those seeking both treatment and aesthetic benefits. The hydration persists through eating and drinking, though reapplication may be needed after meals for maximum glossy effect. Some users might find the fragrance noticeable though not overpowering. The packaging is sleek and travel-friendly, though the product can be difficult to find in some markets outside major beauty retailers.

2Aquaphor Healing Ointment - Best Budget-Friendly Healing Formula

Aquaphor Healing Ointment
$12 - $15
BUY NOWTrusted site: Amazon.com
Aquaphor Healing Ointment provides exceptional healing for severely chapped lips at an affordable price, with dermatologist-recommended ingredients that repair and protect.
  • +Contains 41% petrolatum for superior moisture retention
  • +Fragrance-free and suitable for sensitive skin
  • +Multipurpose use for lips and other dry areas
  • -Thick texture may feel heavy for daytime wear
  • -Requires finger application from tub packaging
  • -Not as cosmetically elegant as some options

Aquaphor Healing Ointment remains a dermatologist favorite for treating severely dry or chapped lips due to its potent combination of petrolatum, mineral oil, and skin-soothing ingredients like panthenol and bisabolol. The formula creates an effective occlusive barrier that prevents moisture loss while allowing damaged skin to heal. Unlike many specialty lip products, Aquaphor offers exceptional value in a versatile formulation that can address dryness anywhere on the body. The ointment proves particularly beneficial for those experiencing extreme dryness from medications like Accutane or harsh weather conditions. While the texture is thicker than traditional lip balms, this density contributes to its long-lasting protective qualities.

The absence of fragrance makes it ideal for sensitive individuals prone to irritation from scented products. Some users may find the need to apply with fingers less hygienic than stick or tube applicators, though travel-sized tubes are available. During testing, the product demonstrated remarkable ability to heal cracked lips overnight when applied generously before bed. While not as aesthetically pleasing as tinted or glossy options, its clinical effectiveness for serious lip repair is unmatched in its price range. The formulation doesn't contain common allergens like lanolin or beeswax, making it suitable for those with specific sensitivities.

3Rhode Peptide Lip Treatment - Best Glossy Hydration with Peptide Technology

Rhode Peptide Lip Treatment
$22 - $24
BUY NOWTrusted site: Amazon.com
Rhode Peptide Lip Treatment combines skincare benefits with a luxurious glossy finish, delivering hydration and subtle plumping effects through its peptide-infused formula.
  • +Contains plumping peptides for improved lip texture
  • +Provides high-shine finish without stickiness
  • +Subtle sweet taste without artificial flavor
  • -Glossy finish may transfer more than matte formulas
  • -Limited shade range for tinted versions
  • -Applicator tip can develop dried product buildup

The Rhode Peptide Lip Treatment has gained significant attention for its ability to deliver both cosmetic appeal and skincare benefits. The formula contains a blend of peptides known to support collagen production alongside hydrating ingredients like shea butter and babassu oil. This combination provides immediate glossy shine while working to improve lip texture over time. Unlike many sticky glosses, the treatment maintains a smooth, fluid texture that feels comfortable throughout wear. The product comes in both clear and lightly tinted versions, though the color payoff remains subtle enough for natural daytime wear. Testing revealed impressive staying power for a glossy formula, with hydration lasting through conversation and light drinking. The peptide complex offers mild plumping effects without the irritation associated with traditional plumping products.

While the applicator allows for precise application, some users noted occasional dried product at the tip that required wiping. The fragrance-free formula makes it suitable for sensitive users, though those preferring scented options might find it lacking. The packaging is sleek and portable, though the squeeze tube requires careful pressure to dispense the right amount. Performance exceeds many luxury department store options at a more accessible price point, making it a standout in the peptide lip treatment category. Those seeking dramatic color may need to layer it over lipstick, but it excels as a standalone hydrating gloss.

4Dr. Dan's Cortibalm - Best Medicated Treatment for Severely Chapped Lips

Dr. Dan's Cortibalm
$7 - $12
BUY NOWTrusted site: Amazon.com
Dr. Dan's Cortibalm provides clinical-strength relief for severely chapped lips with its 1% hydrocortisone formula, offering healing beyond standard moisturization.
  • +Contains 1% hydrocortisone for inflammation relief
  • +Hypoallergenic formula avoids common irritants
  • +Effective for extreme dryness from medications or weather
  • -Medicated formula not for everyday preventive use
  • -Requires consistent application for best results
  • -Limited availability in physical stores

Dr. Dan's Cortibalm fills a unique niche in the lip care market as a medicated solution for severe lip conditions. The inclusion of 1% hydrocortisone sets it apart from standard balms, providing genuine anti-inflammatory action to heal cracked, irritated lips. This makes it particularly valuable for individuals experiencing extreme dryness from medications like Accutane or harsh environmental conditions. The formula avoids common irritants found in many medicated lip products, such as menthol or camphor, instead relying on a simple blend of petroleum jelly, mineral oil, and beeswax alongside its active ingredient. Testing showed noticeable improvement in severely chapped lips within 24-48 hours of regular use, with reduced redness and flaking.

The texture is thicker than basic balms but spreads easily without greasiness. Unlike some medicated options, it has minimal taste or scent, making it more pleasant for regular use during healing periods. Dermatologists frequently recommend this product due to its clinical effectiveness and hypoallergenic properties. While not intended as an everyday preventive balm, it serves as an invaluable rescue treatment when lips become painfully dry. The tube packaging keeps the product sanitary and portable, though some users may prefer stick applicators for convenience. Those with chronic lip conditions may need to use it intermittently under medical guidance due to the steroid content.

5Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm - Best Scented Luxury Balm with Buildable Color

Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm
$22 - $28
BUY NOWTrusted site: Amazon.com
Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm combines indulgent scents with serious hydration, offering a luxurious sensory experience alongside effective lip treatment.
  • +Contains hydrating murumuru and shea butters
  • +Offers delicious scents without artificial taste
  • +Buildable color in flattering shades
  • -Higher price point for amount of product
  • -Some scents may be too strong for sensitive users
  • -Thick texture requires precise application

Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm has earned its popularity through a winning combination of effective hydration and indulgent sensory appeal. The formula relies on rich emollients like murumuru butter and shea butter to deliver lasting moisture, while vegan waxes provide structure without animal-derived ingredients. Available in multiple scented varieties, each version offers a distinct flavor experience from vanilla to fruity options, all without artificial aftertaste. The balm's texture strikes a balance between thick enough to provide substantial hydration yet smooth enough for easy application. Tinted versions provide buildable color that can range from sheer to moderately opaque with layering. Testing showed impressive staying power, with color and hydration lasting through several hours of normal activity.

The slanted applicator tip allows for precise placement, though the dense formula requires some pressure to dispense. While the price positions it as a premium product, the quality of ingredients and performance justify the cost for those seeking a treat-like experience. The packaging is sleek and Instagram-worthy, though the metal tube can dent if carried loosely in bags. Those sensitive to fragrance may prefer the unscented version, but most users find the scents pleasant without being overpowering. The product works well alone or as a hydrating topper over lip liner for enhanced color payoff.

Review updated at 2025-04-28

Comments

Comments are moderated. Please keep the conversation respectful and constructive.

0 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!